BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y 2023: In-Depth Comparison

When comparing electric vehicles, two brands that come to mind are BMW and Tesla. Both are known for their innovative approach to the automotive industry and their luxurious designs. So when choosing between the BMW i4 and the Tesla Model Y, you might find yourself in a bit of a quandary.

This article’ll explore the key differences and similarities between these two impressive vehicles. By understanding the various aspects of each car, such as performance, features, and pricing, you’ll be better equipped to make an informed decision that suits your needs and preferences.

While the BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y offer an excellent driving experience, they each have distinct characteristics. Comparing them will provide valuable insights into which electric vehicle may be your better choice.

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y

Design and Styling

The BMW i4 measures 185.9 inches in length, 72.9 inches in width, and 57.2 inches in height. This makes it a sleek and sporty sedan with a slightly longer and wider stance than its counterpart. On the other hand, the Tesla Model Y, a crossover SUV, has a length of 187.0 inches, a width of 75.6 inches, and a height of 63.9 inches. Due to its form factor, the Model Y offers more headroom and a taller stance for a commanding presence on the road.

As for exterior colors, both the BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y provide a variety of choices to suit your personal style. The i4 offers colors such as Alpine White, Mineral White Metallic, Sunset Orange Metallic, and several others. Meanwhile, the Model Y comes in options like Pearl White Multi-Coat, Solid Black, Midnight Silver Metallic, and others. Both vehicles offer an appealing range of colors to match your preferences.

Regarding design and styling, the BMW i4 features the iconic kidney grille and sharp lines running across the body, giving it a dynamic and modern appearance. The i4 also has adaptive LED headlights and a sculpted rear end for a more aggressive look. In contrast, the Tesla Model Y follows the minimalist design philosophy with a sleek, uninterrupted silhouette and signature LED light blades. The Model Y’s simple yet futuristic aesthetics, including the panoramic glass roof, make it stand out.

Performance and Range

Regarding power, the BMW i4 M50 boasts a remarkable 544 horsepower, while the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD comes in with an impressive 384 horsepower. This clearly shows that the BMW i4 has an edge in raw power. However, don’t forget that torque is also a crucial aspect of performance. There isn’t a noticeable difference here, as the BMW i4 M50 has 586 lb-ft of torque, while the Model Y has 375 lb-ft.

Regarding the range, both vehicles are pretty competitive. The BMW i4 has an estimated maximum range of 300 miles with its 83.9 kWh battery, while the Tesla Model Y, with its 82 kWh battery, offers a slightly longer range of 330 miles. With such minimal difference, it comes down to your preferences and driving habits.

The drivetrain of both vehicles features all-wheel-drive systems, ensuring optimal traction and stability on different road conditions. This contributes to their impressive acceleration times. BMW i4 M50 can sprint from 0 to 60 mph in just 3.7 seconds, while the Tesla Model Y takes only 3.5 seconds for the same task, making it slightly quicker off the line.

Lastly, let’s compare their top speeds. The BMW i4 can reach a top speed of around 124 mph, while the Tesla Model Y takes it a step further, with a top speed of approximately 150 mph. Although both vehicles are undoubtedly fast, the Model Y packs an extra punch in this department.

Battery and Charging

The BMW i4 comes equipped with an 83.9 kWh battery pack, while the Tesla Model Y offers a slightly smaller battery capacity, with the Long Range AWD model featuring a 75 kWh battery. This difference in battery size translates to a 240-mile EPA range for the i4, compared to the 303-mile range of the Model Y.

Regarding charging, both vehicles come equipped with 11 kW on-board chargers (AC). However, Tesla’s Model Y has the advantage in fast charging, with a max charging power (DC) of 250 kW, significantly faster than the i4’s 200 kW limit.

Additionally, both vehicles incorporate the benefit of regenerative braking. This feature helps improve overall efficiency by converting the energy generated during braking back into power for the battery.

When examining voltage, it is important to note that while specific voltage numbers for the i4 are not readily available, Tesla’s Model Y utilizes a 400-volt electrical system. Keep in mind that higher voltage can contribute to reduced charging times.

Interior and Comfort

The BMW i4 offers premium interior materials, fine stitching and high-quality leather. The plush seats provide exceptional comfort for front and rear passengers. You’ll find ample headroom and legroom throughout the cabin, ensuring a comfortable journey for all occupants. As for climate control, the BMW i4 has advanced systems designed to keep you comfortable in varying weather conditions.

On the other hand, the Tesla Model Y features a minimalist cabin with a clean, uncluttered design that maximizes space. The seats in the Model Y are known to be comfortable, offering good support for long drives. In terms of headroom and legroom, it competes closely with the i4, making it comparable in overall comfort. The Model Y’s interior trim options are more limited than those of the i4, but you can still find stylish options that suit your taste. The climate control in the Model Y operates efficiently, utilizing the car’s electric power source to maintain a consistent interior temperature.

Both the BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y provide an array of optional features to enhance your driving experience further. These options include heated and ventilated seats, panoramic sunroofs, and advanced infotainment systems. The i4 boasts the latest BMW iDrive system, while the Model Y features Tesla’s signature touch-screen display, which controls most of the vehicle’s functions.

In terms of seating capacity, the Tesla Model Y has the edge, offering an optional third row for a total of seven passengers. The BMW i4, like most sedans, seats five people comfortably. The Model Y might be a better fit for you if additional seating is essential.

Technology and Features

BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y

The infotainment systems in the BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y are top-notch. In the i4, you’ll enjoy a great multimedia system with a touch screen, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto compatibility. The large, curved display combines a digital instrument cluster and infotainment under one panel, allowing seamless control of various functions. BMW also offers features such as adaptive cruise control and a surround-view camera.

On the other hand, Tesla Model Y boasts arguably the best software in the business with its renowned touch screen. Tesla’s infotainment system offers unique features such as in-car video streaming, gaming, and the famous “fart mode.” As a Tesla owner, you’ll also benefit from the advanced Autopilot system, which provides enhanced cruise control, traffic-aware acceleration, and Autosteer. This makes long commutes more enjoyable and stress-free. Additionally, the Model Y is equipped with a built-in garage door opener, simplifying your daily routine.

Both vehicles showcase innovative tech that excels in different areas. While the BMW i4 focuses on a premium multimedia experience with familiar tools like CarPlay and Android Auto, the Tesla Model Y strives to impress with unique functionality and advanced driving aids. As you compare the BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y, focus on which technology features best suit your driving style and preferences. Good luck in finding the perfect EV that fits your needs!

Safety and Ratings

The BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y have many safety features designed to protect you and your passengers. Standard features include airbags, power windows, and an advanced safety suite that includes technology like automatic emergency braking and adaptive cruise control1. Additionally, some models of the Tesla Model Y come equipped with a heated steering wheel, adding a touch of luxury and comfort on cold days.

Regarding safety ratings, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) gives the Tesla Model Y a 5-star rating, the highest possible score2. Meanwhile, specific safety ratings for the BMW i4 are currently unavailable. However, given BMW’s reputation for building safe vehicles, it’s likely that the i4 will perform well in safety tests.


  1. TrueCar
  2. iSeeCars

Pricing and Costs

The base price of the BMW i4 is around $67,190, while the Tesla Model Y starts at a relatively lower $51,559. However, it’s essential to remember that these prices can vary depending on the features and options you choose for your vehicle.

Apart from the purchasing price, running costs such as electric charging and maintenance should be considered. While both vehicles have electric powertrains and are known for their efficiency, the BMW i4 offers an estimated MPGe (Miles per gallon equivalent). In contrast, the Tesla Model Y has a slightly higher MPGe. Check out each car’s electric efficiency to decide what works best for you.

In terms of warranty, the BMW i4 offers a basic warranty, which typically covers repairs and components for a certain period. However, Tesla Model Y’s warranty could be a deciding factor for some, as Tesla is known for its comprehensive coverage, providing a more extended period of protection.

Additionally, you might want to factor in insurance costs when comparing the BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y. While insurance rates will depend on various factors such as your location, driving history, and selected coverage, the BMW i4 might have a lower insurance payment than the Tesla Model Y, making it a more cost-effective option in this regard.

Additional Comparisons

First, let’s touch on the wheels and suspension systems. The BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y are equipped with alloy wheels, although the sizes may vary depending on the trim or configuration. As for the suspension, the Tesla Model Y utilizes a more advanced air suspension system, while the BMW i4 employs a traditional coil-spring setup. The differences in rest can impact ride quality, so you’ll want to consider your driving preferences when making your decision.

Now, let’s discuss the transmission and electric powertrain aspects. Both vehicles are electric cars, meaning they do not have traditional internal combustion engines or multi-speed transmissions. Instead, they both utilize a single-speed reduction gear transmission and electric motors to deliver power to the wheels, making for a smooth and seamless driving experience.

The BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y also differ in battery size and capacity. While the exact kWh ratings for both vehicles may be subject to change, it’s worth noting that the Tesla Model Y has a larger battery pack as compared to the BMW i4. This can lead to longer-range capabilities, but it’s essential also to consider factors such as charging infrastructure and vehicle efficiency when comparing electric cars.

Lastly, considering how these two electric vehicles compare to other models in their respective lineups is worth it. The Tesla Model Y falls in between the more budget-friendly Model 3 and the larger, more upscale Tesla Model S in terms of size and price. Meanwhile, the BMW i4 sits as a midsize sedan within the German automaker’s growing i-Series lineup.

Our Verdict

There are several aspects to consider when comparing the BMW i4 and the Tesla Model Y. Both electric vehicles have their own set of advantages and drawbacks.

The BMW i4 boasts a more efficient driving experience with 115 MPGe in the city and 111 MPGe on the highway. Furthermore, the BMW i4 is considered less expensive than the Tesla Model Y. The i4 also offers more advanced safety features, which should be an important factor when choosing a new vehicle.

On the other hand, the Tesla Model Y exhibits significantly better mileage, achieving 127 MPGe in the city and 117 MPGe on the highway. The Model Y also has a more powerful base engine, generating 425 horsepower than the i4’s 281 horsepower.

In terms of design and practicality, both vehicles have their own unique qualities that appeal to different preferences. You might be drawn to the sleek and modern design of the Tesla Model Y or the more traditional and luxurious appearance of the BMW i4.

Ultimately, the choice between the BMW i4 and Tesla Model Y heavily depends on your needs, budget, and personal preferences. It is crucial to weigh the pros and cons and test drive both vehicles before making a final decision. Whichever car you choose, know that you’ll be getting a powerful and eco-friendly electric vehicle that’s sure to impress.


What BMW is faster than Tesla?

The BMW M3 is faster than the Tesla Model 3 Performance, thanks to its all-wheel-drive system. While Tesla’s electric vehicles are generally seen as some of the fastest cars in the world, the BMW M3 has been able to beat them in some drag races. 

Why the Model Y is the best car?

The Model Y is the best car due to its combination of world-class drivetrain and technology, spacious interior, and long driving range. It also has instant throttle response and quick acceleration, making it a fun car.

Is Tesla more luxury than BMW?

Tesla is often considered a luxury brand, and its vehicles are priced similarly to luxury cars from BMW. However, BMW has been a well-established luxury car brand for many years, and its reputation and history in the automotive industry may give it an edge over Tesla in terms of perceived luxury. 

Is Tesla worth more than BMW?

Tesla’s market capitalization is higher than BMW’s. Tesla’s worth is approximately $300 billion, while BMW’s is around $50 billion. However, market capitalization can fluctuate based on various factors, and it’s important to note that BMW is a well-established automaker with a long history.

If you liked this blog article about the topic: BMW i4 vs Tesla Model Y, don’t forget to leave us a comment down below to tell us about your experience.

Avatar photo
Elisa Ferry
Articles: 51

One comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *